home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0667>
- <title>
- May 23, 1994: Iraq:No Longer Fenced In
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- May 23, 1994 Cosmic Crash
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- IRAQ, Page 36
- No Longer Fenced In
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> Saddam is back in business as usual, wriggling out of the international
- embargo and rebuilding his weapons-procurement network
- </p>
- <p>By Thomas Sancton/Paris--Reported by Bruce Crumley/Paris and Kenneth R. Timmerman/Washington
- </p>
- <p> On March 3, 1991, under a hastily pitched tent at Safwan air
- base in southern Iraq, General Norman Schwarzkopf gazed across
- the table at two grim-faced Iraqi generals and calmly dictated
- cease-fire terms that put an end to the six-week Gulf War. Stunned
- to learn that the U.S.-led forces had captured more than 60,000
- of his soldiers, Iraqi Lieut. General Sultan Hashim Ahmad al-Jabbari
- acceded to each and every condition. "His face went completely
- pale," Schwarzkopf later recounted. "He had had no concept of
- the magnitude of their defeat."
- </p>
- <p> Nor has the regime of Saddam Hussein fully accepted its defeat
- to this day. Although the West expected his warmaking capacity
- to be blunted once and for all, Saddam has gone back to business
- as usual. In defiance of U.N. sanctions that ban nonhumanitarian
- trade and clamp an embargo on arms sales to Baghdad, he is working
- to rebuild his military and industrial might. Helping him are
- middlemen, front companies, compliant neighbors and Western
- businessmen eager to reforge commercial contacts with a big
- potential customer and the possessor of the world's second-largest
- oil reserves.
- </p>
- <p> Saddam doesn't always have to defy the U.N. to achieve his goals.
- Although Security Council resolutions forbid Iraq to possess
- or develop weapons of mass destruction, they place no such ban
- on his conventional-arms industry. Using a clandestine technology-procurement
- network never fully dismantled, Saddam continues to buy spare
- parts for T-72 tanks in China and Russia, antitank and air-defense
- missiles from Bulgaria, and may now be turning to West European
- firms for critical electronics for his air force. At the same
- time, he has pressed forward with Iraq's ballistic-missile research
- at newly built laboratories. With a leaner and meaner fighting
- machine of about 400,000 troops, Iraq still has the largest
- army in the region.
- </p>
- <p> Anticipating the end of sanctions, Iraq has negotiated a batch
- of trade agreements with France, Turkey and Russia, and has
- even been discussing new contracts with U.S. companies. A loophole
- in the sanctions allows foreign companies to set up deals with
- Iraq that will take effect once the U.N. embargo is lifted.
- The French, Italians, Russians and Turks have interpreted this
- to mean they can enter contractual relationships; the U.S. has
- not. "It would be stupid for us to be the last ones in, when
- everyone else is lining up to sign contracts for Iraq's reconstruction,"
- says General Jeannou Lacaze, retired chief of staff of the French
- armed forces.
- </p>
- <p> Saddam is already on the verge of winning an important U.N.
- concession: a partial reopening of Iraq's oil pipeline through
- Turkey. Periodically Baghdad will be allowed to "flush" the
- pipeline of old oil--which the Turks claim is corroding the
- pipe--and fill it with fresh oil. Each flush will yield about
- 12 million bbl. of marketable oil, which would net Iraq some
- $50 million, and there could be several such operations every
- year.
- </p>
- <p> Turkish officials, who say they are sacrificing $250 million
- annually in lost pipeline fees, insist that Iraq will get only
- humanitarian aid--not cash--in exchange for its oil. They
- promise to refine and use the oil domestically, so it will not
- upset the world petroleum market. The very idea of limited oil
- sales for Iraq is anathema to the U.S. But Washington will reluctantly
- go along with the Security Council plan because the U.S. does
- not want to offend Turkey, an important friend that allows American
- jets based on its soil to patrol Iraqi airspace. "Turkey is
- a good ally," says an American diplomat at the U.N. "We are
- sympathetic to Turkey's needs."
- </p>
- <p> This week, as he does every 60 days, Iraq's Deputy Prime Minister
- Tariq Aziz will meet with the U.N. sanctions committee in New
- York City to argue for an end to the embargo. His previous entreaties
- were flatly rejected, but this time he will find growing support.
- Three of the five permanent members--France, Russia and China--want the trade bans eased. All three stand to win lucrative
- contracts to repair Iraq's infrastructure. France and Russia,
- among Saddam's major prewar trading partners, hope Baghdad could
- begin paying off its massive debts.
- </p>
- <p> The U.S. and Britain insist that Iraq must first comply with
- every condition in the U.N. resolutions that ended the Gulf
- War. Baghdad argues that its recent cooperation with U.N. arms
- inspections is compliance enough. But U.S. officials doubt Saddam
- has renounced his dreams of regional dominance. Moreover, he
- is violating the U.N. resolutions on two key points by refusing
- to acknowledge Kuwait's independence and by committing human-rights
- violations against Iraq's Kurds and Shi`ites. Says Secretary
- of State Warren Christopher: "The stakes are too high to give
- Iraq the benefit of the doubt or to let our policy be dictated
- by commercial interests or simple fatigue."
- </p>
- <p> No one doubts that the sanctions are biting. Inflation in Iraq
- has soared to 250% of prewar levels, while living standards
- have plunged by half. Both as a money-saving move and a hedge
- against defections of senior diplomats, Baghdad has recently
- had to close 15 embassies. The question facing Western policymakers
- is whether Saddam's intensified lobbying to end the embargo
- shows last-ditch desperation, which would argue for keeping
- up the pressure in hopes of toppling the regime, or whether
- Saddam has successfully ridden out the storm. In any event,
- his strategy is clever and multipronged:
- </p>
- <p> TACTICAL TWO-STEP. The pipeline deal is the first tangible gain
- from a tactical about-face by Saddam. After resisting efforts
- to monitor his capabilities for nuclear, biological and chemical
- warfare, he suddenly announced last November that his regime
- would comply fully with U.N. inspectors. Since then, Iraq appears
- to have done so.
- </p>
- <p> Hans Blix, director general of the International Atomic Energy
- Agency, reported last October that "in all essential aspects,
- the nuclear-weapons program is mapped and has been destroyed
- through the war or neutralized thereafter." Rolf Ekeus, chairman
- of the U.N. monitoring team, believes Baghdad's chemical programs
- have been dismantled. Ekeus is also confident that his men have
- accounted for all 890 Scud-B missiles Iraq bought from the Soviet
- Union during the 1970s and '80s. But he still has doubts that
- Iraq has destroyed its biological-weapons program.
- </p>
- <p> Saddam's aim is plainly to fulfill the letter of U.N. law by
- coming clean about Iraq's unconventional-weapons programs in
- order to get the sanctions lifted. But monitors like Ekeus suspect
- he has no intention of obeying the spirit of the ban. Iraq may
- already be secretly reviving its long-range missile program.
- Scientists continue to pursue ballistic-missile research, not
- only at sites destroyed during the war and rebuilt, such as
- the Saad 16 research and development center near Mosul, but
- in new facilities such as Ibn al-Haytham lab, constructed near
- Baghdad. While U.N. resolutions allow Iraq to build short-range
- rockets with a range under 93 miles, a U.N. expert notes "the
- same technology used to make a missile that flies 93 miles can
- be used on one that flies 400 or 1,200 miles."
- </p>
- <p> U.N. inspectors insist on long-term monitoring to make sure
- Iraq does not resume development of mass-destruction weapons
- once sanctions are eased. "The Security Council does not trust
- Iraq's intentions," says Ekeus, "and for as long as that suspicion
- continues, we will continue our monitoring efforts."
- </p>
- <p> SHOPPING NETWORK. There are clear indications that Saddam has
- reopened his high-tech procurement network. In June 1993 the
- Egyptian navy intercepted a freighter carrying hydrochloric
- acid from India outside the Gulf of Aqaba. Experts said Iraq
- could use the chemical for uranium enrichment.
- </p>
- <p> Six months later, German and Saudi officials detained a German-registered
- ship, the Asian Senator, as it steamed past a Saudi port en
- route to Beirut. On board, they seized two containers of Chinese-produced
- ammonium perchlorate, an essential ingredient for solid-fuel
- rockets and ballistic missiles. Though the ostensible destination
- was Lebanon, U.N. monitors and U.S. officials confirmed that
- the real end user was Iraq's long-range missile program.
- </p>
- <p> U.S. customs officials are investigating half a dozen cases
- in which Iraq allegedly broke sanctions. However, "for every
- case we see," says one of the agents, "there's probably a hundred
- potential violators out there." According to congressional investigators,
- many front companies established in the late 1980s to purchase
- parts and technology for Saddam's weapons programs continue
- to operate in France, Switzerland, Germany, Britain and the
- U.S. Last month American customs agents arrested a pair of Jordanian
- nationals, Al. M. Harb and his wife Rula Saba Harb, on charges
- of using a home-based front company in Midlothian, Virginia,
- to circumvent the Iraqi embargo. Court documents show that the
- couple made more than 100 shipments to Iraq over the past three
- years, including equipment that could be used for ballistic
- missiles and nuclear weapons. "These aren't the Rosenbergs,"
- says a customs agent. "But we have established that they shipped
- equipment and spare parts of potential use to a revived Iraqi
- bomb program." The couple have been indicted for violating the
- Iraq embargo and will go on trial in mid-June.
- </p>
- <p> To finance its arms programs, Baghdad is constantly trying to
- persuade the U.N. to release its billions of dollars of frozen
- assets on the pretext of buying "humanitarian" supplies. So
- far, with the agreement of the sanctions committee, the Iraqis
- have managed to get back more than $250 million for humanitarian
- purchases, most of it from British and Swiss banks.
- </p>
- <p> OLD FRIENDS. France, which enjoyed cozy commercial ties with
- Iraq before the war, is particularly eager to loosen trade strictures.
- So far, the war and the embargo have cost taxpayers an estimated
- $8.7 billion in unpaid government-guaranteed loans, and Paris
- wants to get the money back.
- </p>
- <p> At the same time, French companies that did big business with
- Baghdad want to resume a lucrative connection. State-owned oil
- giants Elf Aquitaine and Total were the first Western firms
- to make contact with Baghdad after the war. Iraqi authorities
- proposed to give the two French companies a rich production
- monopoly developing the Majnoun Islands and Nahr Umar oilfields,
- which could produce 1 million bbl. a day. In exchange, the Iraqis
- wanted the French to lobby for lifting U.N. sanctions. Since
- then, according to the weekly Canard Enchaine, representatives
- of the two companies have made more than 40 trips to Baghdad
- and preliminary contracts have been drawn up. The French government
- has frozen the deal until sanctions are lifted, though a Foreign
- Ministry spokesman insists that "we have nothing against such
- contacts."
- </p>
- <p> Baghdad is trying to attract Russia by offering major contracts
- for oil exploration and rebuilding refineries. In February the
- Italian gas company Italgaz sent a high-level delegation to
- Iraq, followed last month by representatives of 30 leading Italian
- companies, including Fiat autos and International Scientifica,
- a medical-equipment maker. British, German and Japanese firms
- have also been poking around the bazaar.
- </p>
- <p> Nor have Americans been wholly absent. According to Western
- diplomats and business travelers, agents of Occidental Petroleum,
- Chevron, Boeing, General Motors and others have been spotted
- in the first-class hotels of Baghdad and Amman, Jordan, where
- many of the meetings with Iraqi trade officials take place.
- State Department officials say they have investigated these
- claims and found no sign of wrongdoing by U.S. companies, who
- are "officially discouraged" from making such contacts. Says
- a State Department official: "The Iraqis are engaged in a constant
- effort to get companies to deal with them quickly. They want
- them to believe the train is leaving the station and that they
- will be left behind if they don't jump on board."
- </p>
- <p> Considering the potentially dire consequences--economic, military
- and diplomatic--of a hasty return to doing business with Iraq,
- the U.S. wants to err on the side of caution. That is also the
- position of the U.N. inspectors, who bear primary responsibility
- for making sure that Saddam's infernal death machine does not
- spring back to life. If the sanctions are lifted and the Iraqis
- renege on their promises, putting the restrictions back again
- may prove to be too little, too late.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-